Can an atheist marry someone of faith?

General philosophy message board for Discussion and debate on other philosophical issues not directly related to veganism. Metaphysics, religion, theist vs. atheist debates, politics, general science discussion, etc.

Can an atheist marry a catholic?

Yes
16
89%
No
2
11%
 
Total votes: 18

User avatar
brimstoneSalad
neither stone nor salad
Posts: 10370
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 9:20 am
Diet: Vegan

Re: Can an atheist marry someone of faith?

Post by brimstoneSalad »

EquALLity wrote:What exactly do you mean by 'functional nihilist'?
Despite thinking they care about things (or wanting to call themselves good people) they behave as nihilists because they rationalize away bad behavior and dismiss the relevance of ethics.

This, however, has more to do with personal behavior than policy:
brimstoneSalad wrote:as long as they're also comfortable first
Chinese politicians will be disgustingly rich, will smoke and eat meat, etc. However, as long as their policy decisions don't affect them personally (which they won't, due to their wealth) they can make pragmatic decisions about what is best for the general population.

We see the same thing reflected in the general public too. People are more willing to support relatively extreme measures of animal welfare as law, while not being willing to abstain from supporting equally extreme harm to animals in their personal lives through consumer choice.
User avatar
EquALLity
I am God
Posts: 3022
Joined: Thu Jul 10, 2014 11:31 am
Diet: Vegan
Location: United States of Canada

Re: Can an atheist marry someone of faith?

Post by EquALLity »

brimstoneSalad wrote:Despite thinking they care about things (or wanting to call themselves good people) they behave as nihilists because they rationalize away bad behavior and dismiss the relevance of ethics.
Alright, is there actual evidence for this, though (that the majority of people are nihilists)?
How much of the majority, also?
"I am not a Marxist." -Karl Marx
User avatar
brimstoneSalad
neither stone nor salad
Posts: 10370
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 9:20 am
Diet: Vegan

Re: Can an atheist marry someone of faith?

Post by brimstoneSalad »

EquALLity wrote:Alright, is there actual evidence for this, though (that the majority of people are nihilists)?
How much of the majority, also?
Functional nihilists. They just go with whatever is easy in society. They don't actually claim to be so. You just have to look at behavior in terms of that which deviates from social convention out of moral purposes, rather than rationalization.

http://www.npr.org/sections/goatsandsod ... -unethical

This would suggest 85% of people are functionally nihilists.
Interestingly, this also generally reflects statistics on vegetarians, both how many people ever try to go veg in their lives, and recidivism:

http://nymag.com/scienceofus/2014/12/84 ... -meat.html

You'll find numbers around that range for a lot of things.
CXC0401
Newbie
Posts: 26
Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 7:16 pm
Diet: Meat-Eater

Re: Can an atheist marry someone of faith?

Post by CXC0401 »

ArmouredAbolitionist wrote:
Regardless of whether or not veganism is something you care about, I'd insist that it's important to have strong values (whatever they may be) in common with your boyfriend, and that this might be enough to have a good relationship. Sorry if I wrote too much.
I appreciate everyone's input and have been reading every word, so thank you!

The only reason I didn't want to respond to the question is because I didn't want to get into a debate or discussion about veganism. Personally both my boyfriend and I are not vegans, and even if it were something that I were to think about in the future my life right now is very overwhelmed with leaving my faith and figuring out who I am in that sense. It is overwhelming enough as it is, and it might be something in due time, just not now.

But I agree that we need to have some deeper common ground between us, and while I could argue and say that we do about some things I'm not sure if that would be enough to propel us further, especially since religion is something he deeply cares about.
CXC0401
Newbie
Posts: 26
Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 7:16 pm
Diet: Meat-Eater

Re: Can an atheist marry someone of faith?

Post by CXC0401 »

brimstoneSalad wrote:For example, the owner of this site is married to a religious woman, but they are both vegan and because they share that (and society at large has very poor values in that respect) there may be enough common ground to keep them together despite other differences.

Kind of how in the movies when the alien hordes come to destroy the Earth, everybody unites together.

The biggest thing there is sharing certain values -- not just typical values we can take for granted that any bum off the street has like being against genocide, but special or extraordinary values that bring you two together against the tide of human apathy and misery.

Most people are functionally nihilists, and when couples don't share common values, there's nothing really keeping them together. And no, children definitely don't fix that (contrary to popular belief).
I guess I never really thought about that, and I responded (above) to that quote. But it would definitely be something in the future, not right now.
User avatar
brimstoneSalad
neither stone nor salad
Posts: 10370
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 9:20 am
Diet: Vegan

Re: Can an atheist marry someone of faith?

Post by brimstoneSalad »

CXC0401 wrote:even if it were something that I were to think about in the future my life right now is very overwhelmed with leaving my faith and figuring out who I am in that sense. It is overwhelming enough as it is, and it might be something in due time, just not now.
I certainly understand what you mean, and I think we've all felt that way at one time or another. Although it's worth noting that getting in touch with your secular values could be a crucial part of figuring out who you are without religion. Religion leaves a big hole, in terms of knowing what's right and wrong.

Many atheists turn to hedonism and nihilism -- you'll hear some people say they don't care if other human beings, let alone other animals, suffer and die for their pleasure, as long as it doesn't negatively affect them personally. E.g. as long as it's legal, and not somebody they care about, a stranger can be tortured to death and they don't blink.

Of course, these people are rarely happy. Focusing on oneself and one's own issues often just exacerbates our stress and self pity in life, and seeking happiness directly is one of the surest ways never to find it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_hedonism

By learning about the core of who you are as a good human being, and focusing on helping others, you can become more fulfilled and your own existential troubles will become a distant memory. You'll never for a moment lose touch with who you are as long as you spend your life becoming the best person you can be. Our sense of identity is very much about actions, not all of those often answer-less existential questions.
CXC0401 wrote:But I agree that we need to have some deeper common ground between us, and while I could argue and say that we do about some things I'm not sure if that would be enough to propel us further, especially since religion is something he deeply cares about.
All couples tend to think they have deep connections. Sometimes due to emotional reasons -- but the trouble is, those are hormonal (like a drug), and emotions are fleeting. People can fall out of love as quickly as into it, the spell just has to be broken (by time, or by a sudden realization that the relationship isn't right).
And for every inside joke couples have, they usually have similar inside jokes with colleagues and other friends. This is a part of shared culture, and it's very easily acquired -- this is the whole purpose of memes, of course. That won't hold people together either.
Taste in movies, or music, or anything else? Broadly shared, really, by many people out there.

Unfortunately, it's very hard to find true deep commonalities outside religious conviction. Politics are nowhere near that level for most people (but again, essentially half the country is bound to share the majority of your political beliefs either way, so it's rarely a way to bind two people).
Extraordinary secular moral conviction, like veganism, is the only one I know of for sure. It's possible some people feel this way about art, but as soon as creative differences arise... it's not stable.

It's very hard to identify a commonality half as strong as the division created by a religious rift. You'd have to find something you both care about much more than he cares about his religion, and that most other people don't care about much at all.
User avatar
garrethdsouza
Senior Member
Posts: 431
Joined: Mon May 11, 2015 4:47 pm
Diet: Vegan
Location: India

Re: Can an atheist marry someone of faith?

Post by garrethdsouza »

CXC0401 wrote: my life right now is very overwhelmed with leaving my faith and figuring out who I am in that sense.
But I agree that we need to have some deeper common ground between us, and while I could argue and say that we do about some things I'm not sure if that would be enough to propel us further, especially since religion is something he deeply cares about.
Yes becoming atheist can be a bit overwhelming especially socially the more religious the environment you are in. And it might take some time/experience to figure out what you want to do about your atheism/irreligiosity or in life now that you identify as atheist. What do you feel overwhelmed about? Folks out here or other atheist groups may have been through similar experiences and know the ropes so might be able to help. It can also be pretty context/location specific in some ways.

When someone says religion really matters to them especially if they are being very close minded, all I hear is that voluntary self deception/not doing the right thing really matters to them which is kind of sad and morally bankrupt. Religious indoctrination/conformity can be a pretty powerful force, perhaps why its persisted succesfully for so long and social situations can at first be a challenge figuring out that might prevent people from thinking about questioning it.
“We are the cosmos made conscious and life is the means by which the universe understands itself.”

― Brian Cox
CXC0401
Newbie
Posts: 26
Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 7:16 pm
Diet: Meat-Eater

Re: Can an atheist marry someone of faith?

Post by CXC0401 »

garrethdsouza wrote:What do you feel overwhelmed about? Folks out here or other atheist groups may have been through similar experiences and know the ropes so might be able to help. It can also be pretty context/location specific in some ways.

Religious indoctrination/conformity can be a pretty powerful force, perhaps why its persisted succesfully for so long and social situations can at first be a challenge figuring out that might prevent people from thinking about questioning it.
I guess now that I identify as atheist I'm more fully aware at how many people are religious, or at least identify as such. I'm more aware of all of the churches every ten feet on the road and how it is ingrained in politics, on TV; everything. I just see it everywhere. And the thing is that in a country that practices freedom of religion (supposedly) all I ever see on TV is the Christian god being depicted. During Christmas I swear every movie had references to god in some way. And I notice more and more when actors will come out and thank god for their works, or movies in general just depict god. The movie "God's Not Dead" was probably the worst movie I have ever seen; not because it was a Christian movie, but because it actually sucked as a film. Yet I feel like all these Christians support it and praise it because god defeats the atheist (not really an atheist... but whatever) at the end and he's roaring like a lion and blah blah. And now there's a new movie coming out called "Miracles from Heaven." My boyfriend and I saw a trailer for it the last time we were at the theater and I commented that the trailer told you the ENTIRE film (which it does. Like there is no part of the plot that is not revealed in the trailer.) and he still said he wanted to see it. Then again I'm not into chick flicks, and he is... but that's besides the point. There are just all these reminders about the faith I left and honestly no one to talk to. I know it seems like I'm ranting or so confusing but to be completely honest this is the first time I have ever spoken with other atheists... And I hope you all can appreciate how much this means to me.

And obviously sometimes I doubt. Sometimes I wonder if the majority is right. But then I think about it again and end up in the same place... and sometimes it's just a lot to handle and I feel like I'm suffocating.

And an argument that we constantly get into is that I feel like a lot of Catholics are brainwashed. For example, one of my best friends has lesbian mothers, one of whom was raised very Catholic. She never wanted to go out of state to marry her partner because of the reservations she had with the catholic faith. Long story short the gay marriage law was recently passed in Arizona and they got married. I find it frustrating and hypocritical that they are married and proclaiming they are catholic. According to the catholic faith those things CANNOT go together, point blank period. I'm happy for them, I really am, but the marriage between two homosexuals is not allowed. Catholics will defend this by saying they support the LGBTQ community and won't ever turn them away, which is true, but acting upon those 'choices' is a sin, bottom line. Hell, freshman year of high school my friend had to be evaluated for proper parenting because they were worried about the long-term effects of being raised without a mom and a dad, and in the school yearbook senior year they weren't allowed to sign their letters "Mama -- and Mama --" (as we all call them), they had to say either their names or just her parents, I can't remember what they chose.

-back to my boyfriend- He always becomes sarcastic and snarky when I bring this up, saying things like "Well that's all we are is brainwashed catholics huh?" And then typically we stop speaking for a while. That's just the reality of the situation, at least I feel. If he were to be born in an Indian culture, or a Chinese culture, or any other culture that does not practice Catholicism, he most likely wouldn't be a catholic, and I probably wouldn't be an atheist. But he would say that if I raised my children atheist, I would be brainwashing them into believing in atheism.

And to be honest, I really feel like it would be easier to be religious. It would be easier to blame all the bad things on a plan that I can't control and know that I can make up for my sins with a quick Hail Mary and a trip to the confessional. I find it a lot harder to know that every moment here on earth is the only chance I have to make an impression on people, and my hopefully, 90+ years of life are the only chance I have to leave my name in the hearts of the people I meet, good or bad. Unfortunately I made the mistake of bringing this up to my bf, and he used that as reason why I should raise my kid in faith. I just feel like I would be lying to myself and them

**And I'm so immensely excited that Einstein's theory of relativity is failing to be disproven (their sort of proving it, but we can't prove anything in science... as I'm sure you're all aware :? ) because this could give us futher knowledge of how the universe came to be... not that it would turn anyone. But still, cool for me.**

**And yes, yes; I know I'm too young to think about marriage and kids and all that crap... and generally I hate talking about it. I wasn't the first one to bring it up, believe me. It just gets brought up a lot and makes me think about it.**
CXC0401
Newbie
Posts: 26
Joined: Wed Feb 10, 2016 7:16 pm
Diet: Meat-Eater

Re: Can an atheist marry someone of faith?

Post by CXC0401 »

brimstoneSalad wrote: Many atheists turn to hedonism and nihilism -- you'll hear some people say they don't care if other human beings, let alone other animals, suffer and die for their pleasure, as long as it doesn't negatively affect them personally.

All couples tend to think they have deep connections. Sometimes due to emotional reasons -- but the trouble is, those are hormonal (like a drug), and emotions are fleeting. People can fall out of love as quickly as into it, the spell just has to be broken (by time, or by a sudden realization that the relationship isn't right).
I appreciate the advice, I really do. And I know everything you are saying has truth behind it. It's just with everything going on in my life right now leaving him would be really devastating. In my discussions with everyone of course I am talking about the small amount of time that these issues get brought up. We really do work well together otherwise and try not to bring religion into it.

It's just being exacerbated right now because of the season of Lent and he is involved in a Catholic Fraternity, so right now they are especially busy with the easter season.
User avatar
brimstoneSalad
neither stone nor salad
Posts: 10370
Joined: Wed May 28, 2014 9:20 am
Diet: Vegan

Re: Can an atheist marry someone of faith?

Post by brimstoneSalad »

CXC0401 wrote:It's just with everything going on in my life right now leaving him would be really devastating. In my discussions with everyone of course I am talking about the small amount of time that these issues get brought up. We really do work well together otherwise and try not to bring religion into it.
Well, I would encourage you to watch a few documentaries together: Earthlings, Cowspiracy, Forks over Knives
See if you two can relate to each other and connect on a bigger issue than religion.

If you both found that you care about animals, the environment, health, morality, regardless of whether you believe in a god or not, that could be something meaningful you could do together and that would strengthen your relationship.
If you can connect on something else, like going vegetarian (or moving in that direction or something along those lines), that would be meaningful and there'd be real hope that you're in touch on something deeper.

I know I sound like a broken record, but I can't overstate the importance of shared values.

Otherwise, IMO it's better to pull a band-aid off quickly rather than pick at it, and better to have things done sooner rather than waiting and suffering anxiety because of that.
CXC0401 wrote:**And I'm so immensely excited that Einstein's theory of relativity is failing to be disproven (their sort of proving it, but we can't prove anything in science... as I'm sure you're all aware :? ) because this could give us futher knowledge of how the universe came to be... not that it would turn anyone. But still, cool for me.**
I can assure you, relativity is proved, at least as much as the notion that the Earth is round and orbits the sun. It's really undeniable today. Time dilation is used every day in satellite communication, which wouldn't work without relativity being true.

It is of course quite exciting, and I've discussed at some length here how it disproves god as well.
Quantum physics is another subject to go into that has implications as to the origin of reality and religion.

Religion, and the god of theism (at least) is pretty easy to debunk with basic physics.
Post Reply